The Best Options in 2026 - Tested by Experts
Our team spent thousands of hours researching and testing to bring you this definitive ranking. Updated monthly.
Quick Comparison
| Rank | Provider | Rating | Pricing | Best For | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Embrace Pet Insurance Editor's Choice | 4.8 | Dogs from ~$35/mo, Cats from ~$18/mo | Excellent | Visit Site → |
| #2 | Healthy Paws Fastest Claims | 4.7 | Dogs from ~$30/mo, Cats from ~$15/mo | Excellent | Visit Site → |
| #3 | Lemonade Pet Insurance Best Digital Experience | 4.5 | Dogs from ~$25/mo, Cats from ~$12/mo | Very Good | Visit Site → |
| #4 | Trupanion Best for Chronic Conditions | 4.4 | Dogs from ~$45/mo, Cats from ~$25/mo | Very Good | Visit Site → |
| #5 | Spot Pet Insurance Most Customizable | 4.3 | Dogs from ~$28/mo, Cats from ~$14/mo | Very Good | Visit Site → |
| #6 | Pets Best | 4.2 | Dogs from ~$30/mo, Cats from ~$16/mo | Good | Visit Site → |
Detailed Reviews
Embrace Pet Insurance
Embrace consistently earns the highest customer satisfaction ratings in the pet insurance industry. Their diminishing deductible (decreases by $50 each year you don't file a claim), flexible coverage options, and fast claims processing make them our top pick for comprehensive pet insurance.
Pros
- +Diminishing deductible rewards healthy pets - unique in the industry
- +Covers exam fees, which adds $50-$100 per claim vs. competitors that exclude them
- +Highly rated claims experience with fast processing and low denial rates
- +Optional Wellness Rewards plan for routine care at an additional cost
Cons
- −Slightly higher base premiums than the cheapest competitors
- −Wellness plan is a separate add-on, not included in base coverage
- −6-month waiting period for orthopedic conditions (standard in the industry)
Healthy Paws
Healthy Paws is famous for two things: no annual or lifetime payout caps and the fastest claims processing in the industry. Most claims are processed within 2-3 days, and many pet owners report same-day reimbursement. Their straightforward, single-plan structure makes choosing coverage simple.
Pros
- +No caps on payouts - critical for expensive conditions like cancer treatment ($10,000+)
- +Industry-leading claims speed - most processed in 2-3 business days
- +Simple plan structure eliminates confusion about coverage levels
- +Strong customer satisfaction ratings across all review platforms
Cons
- −No wellness or routine care coverage option - accident and illness only
- −Does not cover exam fees
- −Cannot customize deductible and reimbursement as flexibly as some competitors
Lemonade Pet Insurance
Lemonade brings a tech-first approach to pet insurance with AI-powered instant claims, a clean mobile app, and some of the lowest starting premiums in the market. Their base accident and illness plan is very competitively priced, with optional add-ons for wellness, dental, and behavioral therapy.
Pros
- +Lowest starting premiums make coverage accessible for budget-conscious pet owners
- +AI claims processing delivers fastest possible turnaround for simple claims
- +Modern app experience is the best in the pet insurance industry
- +Modular add-ons let you customize coverage to your needs and budget
Cons
- −Add-ons can increase the price significantly - base plan is limited
- −Newer to pet insurance (launched 2020) - shorter track record than established competitors
- −Annual payout limits on base plans ($5,000-$100,000 depending on tier)
Trupanion
Trupanion stands out with direct vet payment - they pay your vet directly at checkout so you never have to front thousands of dollars and wait for reimbursement. Their coverage for chronic and hereditary conditions is among the most comprehensive available, with no per-condition or lifetime caps.
Pros
- +Direct vet payment eliminates the need to pay thousands upfront and wait for reimbursement
- +No caps of any kind - critical for ongoing chronic conditions like diabetes or allergies
- +Excellent hereditary condition coverage for breeds with known health risks
- +30-day money-back guarantee lets you try coverage risk-free
Cons
- −Higher premiums than most competitors - especially for larger breeds
- −Only one reimbursement rate (90%) - no option for lower premiums with lower reimbursement
- −No wellness or routine care coverage available
Spot Pet Insurance
Spot offers the most customizable pet insurance plans on the market. Choose your annual limit ($2,500-unlimited), deductible ($100-$1,000), and reimbursement rate (70%-90%) to build a plan that fits your exact budget and risk tolerance. Their preventive care add-on is among the most generous available.
Pros
- +Maximum plan customization lets you balance coverage and cost precisely
- +No upper age limit for enrollment - covers senior pets many competitors won't
- +Preventive care add-on covers vaccines, dental cleaning, and annual exams
- +Competitive pricing especially for customized mid-tier plans
Cons
- −Newer brand with less track record than Embrace or Healthy Paws
- −Claims processing speed is average (10-14 days reported)
- −Lower annual limit options ($2,500-$5,000) may be insufficient for serious conditions
Pets Best
Pets Best was founded in 2005 by a veterinarian and offers solid accident and illness coverage with one of the most affordable wellness add-ons in the market. Their EssentialWellness and BestWellness plans cover routine care starting at just $16/month, making total coverage (accident + illness + wellness) very competitively priced.
Pros
- +Best value when combining accident/illness + wellness coverage together
- +Affordable wellness add-ons cover vaccines, dental, and routine exams
- +Fast claims processing - 5-day average turnaround
- +Flexible deductible options ($50-$1,000) for budget customization
Cons
- −Annual payout caps on some plan tiers - check limits carefully
- −Customer service reviews are mixed - some report slow response times
- −Exam fee coverage varies by plan tier
How We Rank & Review
Our rankings are the result of a rigorous, multi-step evaluation process. We start with extensive market research to identify every viable option, then narrow the field based on reputation, customer feedback, and feature sets.
Each product on our list undergoes hands-on testing by our expert reviewers. We evaluate ease of setup, day-to-day usability, feature quality, customer support responsiveness, and overall value for money.
We also survey real customers to understand long-term satisfaction and reliability. Our ratings combine expert scores with customer sentiment to give you a complete, balanced picture.
We update these rankings monthly as new products launch, prices change, and we gather more data. Our goal is to always give you the most current, accurate recommendations possible.